The R3 Korea version is probably the best one to get.  There is a version with a limited metal case which is slightly more expensive than the digipack version, and it includes the bonus disc that was mysteriously omitted from the R1 release (probably so they can double dip later on).  There is also an R3 Korea version that includes the comic.

What, Bryan Singer shows up and promises to re-shot the film?

Ah, comon', Ratner did a great job!

I think Ratner is getting an unfair amount of the blame. That's not to say he's blameless but other people such as script writers and studio execs (and to a limited extent, Bryan Singer himself) all share some of the blame. I also feel that Singer would not neccessarily have saved the day (although it would have been better to some extent). After seeing Superman Returns I thought it was highly overrated. I'm not saying the film was rubbish but there were areas where I felt it was severely lacking. It was certainly made with much more care and thought than X-Men 3 but whether or not that extra effort paid off is open for debate as far as I'm concerned.

For me what sums it up is the following. X-Men 3 delivered exactly what I was expecting. I knew it was going to be a flawed movie when you looked at it's production history. Superman failed to deliver what I expected. I was expecting an excellent movie that I had every intention of buying on DVD. Instead what I saw was a good movie that was enjoyable once but I did not feel a need to buy on DVD. Although it has many good points it was at times I felt a very turgid film

In past post on the subject of X 3 I've said that I hoped Ratner would surprise us with a good film and that we should give him a chance. I thought this because I believed he did an ok job with Red Dragon, given the fact that he'd mainly just done videos and Rush Hour movies. Listening to him on the behind the scenes docs on Red Dragon also led me to believe that he was at least putting some thought in to the process.

However, have seen the finished version of X 3 and his behaviour and general attitude on the set of the film, my opinion has shifted. I was wrong to back this horse. He does indeed appear to be a fat loudmouth who, at best, managed to get the quota of set-ups shot each day. What a hero to Fox he must be. He must be first in line for AvP2 or Predator 3.

The film is very 'on the surface' and has no real repeat viewing value.