Black Mask (US - BD RA)
Gabe Powers takes a belated look at superhero Jet Li in high definition...
Feature
A superhuman commando unit code named Squad 701 is marked as too dangerous to continue service, and set for termination. One member escapes to a life of solitude as a librarian, but the easy life is shaken with Hong Kong’s most notorious drug lords begin to be murdered by Squad 701 like operatives. Against his better judgement the librarian dawns a new identity, the Black Mask, and takes measures to stop his former colleagues.

Hong Kong superhero movies are almost undoubtedly fun even when they aren’t very good. The definition of a Hong Kong superhero films is a pretty difficult one to pin down I suppose considering all flying kung fu masters could be considered superheroes, so for the sake of this argument we’ll only be referring to flying kung fu masters with Western comic book origins. My personal favourite is probably Johnny To’s Heroic Trio (Anthony Wong eats his own fingers), but Daniel Lee’s Black Mask is still a pretty fun time, though not quite as much fun as the Tsui Hark directed sequel, which is like some insane episode of Power Rangers.
Black Mask suffers and succeeds in the same ways most of Tsui Hark’s more recent (I’m thinking post Iron Monkey) productions. Hark and French producer extraordinaire Luc Besson both have this tendency to not put a lot of effort into the movies they don’t physically direct, creating medium budget actions films with a few good set pieces and an overwhelming lack of logic. I find it very hard to believe more than a weekend’s worth of work was put into The Black Mask script. The whole thing is a mish mash of wushu, Sam Raimi inspired camera work (a constant favourite of Hark’s[/i], ‘90s Hollywood comic book visual clichés, vague cyber punk elements, some vague elements of The Green Hornet, and some surprisingly graphic violence. The general weirdness and extremity of the violence is the best reason to watch the film.

Now I could have sworn that the box art and opening titles said Lionsgate, but this Blu-ray disc is a maltreated Dimension release at heart. Following the success of Lethal Weapon 4 certain Hollywood types thought it would be a good time to introduce Hong Kong superstar Jet Li to American audiences. The Black Mask was chosen, even though it was already three years old, it was dubbed into English (with a new soundtrack), and cut by something like ten minutes. Thus, as is the fate of so many lamely re-edited Hong Kong films, a non-sequential film is made almost impossibly random.
Video
Lionsgate’s Blu-ray record is still pretty spotty. They get the new releases right, but so far their catalogue titles do not impress. This appears to be an upconverted 1080p transfer, not true HD. The colourful film appears muted, the edges bleed a bit, the hue separation is average at best, and contrast is kind of dim. Details are sharper than the old DVD version, and edge enhancement has been lessened a bit (as I recall, it’s been a while), but the soft and muted look is quite disappointing overall. I can say that the more garish pinks and blues that infiltrate the frame when ever something ‘supernatural’ occurs are very pretty, but that’s pretty much the extent of the transfer’s impressiveness.

Audio
Th3 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio impresses with it’s liveliness, and general noise levels, but the Hollywood remix is awkward and inconsistent. Most of the impressive sound effects are of the canned variety, and most of the stylized, ‘zippy’ sound effects were obviously made using less than state of the art means, which kind of depletes a bit of the over-the-top fun of the mix. The musical cues (most of which I believe were added for the US release) are rigidly obnoxious, but move very effectively though all channels. Honestly though, I could go several days without hearing any more gratuitous record scratching. The English dubbing isn’t too bad, but Lionsgate really should’ve included the original Mandarin and/or Cantonese tracks for the fans.
Extras
These extras are lame, taken directly from the ancient DVD release. ‘Wushu Technique’ is a silly little text essay on the ins and outs of kung fu. ‘Wushu In Action’ is a series of shortcuts to ten of the film’s fights (in Dolby Surround?). This is followed by a text and clip based trivia game and a series of Lionsgate trailers.

Overall
Being released in the states after Blade seemed like too little, too late at the time, but thanks to an attachment to hip-hop culture Black Mask did play an important part in bringing Jet Li successfully to America. It’s just too bad he didn’t make a Western film worth a good god damn until he went to France to hook up with Luc Besson. Fans will be disappointed by the half-assed hi-def video of this disc, and the extras aren’t any more interesting than they were last time.
*Note: The images on this page are not representative of the Blu-ray release.
Review by Gabriel Powers
Advertisements
mc_serenity
Member
Join Date: December 2006
Location: United States
Posts: 691
This movie was fun, particularly with the hilarious dubbing. I'd wish Lionsgate would give this film the treatment it deserves, such as a better transfer, original audio and maybe some worthy extras.
Report
Quote
| Reply
The original music soundtrack is far superior to the horrible Hollywood re-mix (same with John Woo's A Better Tommorrow).
I would recommend readers to buy the Region 3 dvd from Yes.Asia.com (if they have a multi-region player). It is a fun film and is better than most of Jet Li's American films.
I would recommend readers to buy the Region 3 dvd from Yes.Asia.com (if they have a multi-region player). It is a fun film and is better than most of Jet Li's American films.
It's been so long since I saw this movie that I can't remember if I liked it or not. I think this character got sorted and filed to the back of my brain because I automatically lump it in with Kato from the Green Hornet.
Yipeey! The English dub.
:-| :-| :-|
I don't think Lionsgate own the Chinese language rights. They'd also need to recut the audio to match this "USA Cut" too. I cannot see them doing that. It's basically a mess.
p.s - I'll be sticking with my HK SE DVD.
:-| :-| :-|
I don't think Lionsgate own the Chinese language rights. They'd also need to recut the audio to match this "USA Cut" too. I cannot see them doing that. It's basically a mess.
p.s - I'll be sticking with my HK SE DVD.

Disc Details
Release Date:
2nd September 2008
Discs:
1
Disc Type:
Blu-ray Disc
RCE:
No
Video:
1080p
Aspect:
1.78:1
Anamorphic:
No
Colour:
Yes
Audio:
DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 English
Subtitles:
N/A
Extras:
Wushu Techniques, Wushu in Action, Quiz, Trialers
Easter Egg:
No
Feature Details
Director:
Daniel Lee
Cast:
Jet Li, Ching Wan Lau, Françoise Yip, Karen Mok, Anthony Wong
Genre:
Action
Length:
102 minutes


