S.W.A.T. Superbit (US - DVD R1)
Released theatrically in the middle of the 2003 summer movie season, S.W.A.T. became one of the year's highest grossing movie...
S.W.A.T. was released theatrically on August 8th 2003 in the heart of the summer movie season. The eighty million dollar budgeted action film raked in over one hundred million domestically, making it a bona fide blockbuster by the time it hit DVD with a wealth of extras in June of 2004. Columbia Tri-Star has now released a Superbit edition of the title to reward fans of the film with the best possible video and audio presentation. For those of you who’ve seen the film and may own it already, is it worth the double-dip? For those new to the film, is it worth checking out? To be honest Bad Boys II left a poor taste in my mouth and I had a premonition before viewing this film that I would be seeing Bad Boys III. Fortunately, that was not the case...

Film
The movie opens with a great hook for an action movie: members of a S.W.A.T. team in Los Angeles are in the middle of a rescue situation. The team succeeds, but injures a civilian in the process. This causes officer Brian Gamble (Jeremy Renner) to quit, and also sees Jim Street (Colin Farrel) get demoted. A rift between the two former best friends and partners forms as they go their separate ways. Fast-forward five months where veteran Sgt. Hondo Harrelson (played by bona fide bad-ass Samuel L. Jackson) is given the assignment of assembling a new S.W.A.T. team. He enlists the help of Farrell’s character to also recruit officers played by Michelle Rodriguez, LL Cool J, and Josh Charles to formulate the new team for the L.A. Police Department. There are some fun training sequences here, including a poker game in which card hands are obtained by using sniper rifles to hit their cards. The final test for this group to become an activated S.W.A.T. unit occurs in a mock terrorist situation on an airplane. These training sequences are engaging because we get to learn about our heroes throughout the duration of them. This important detail will make the real action sequences better and more meaningful. Samuel L. Jackson (best known for his role in Pulp Fiction) is wonderful in his role as a mentor to the rest of his team, trying to keep things cool under pressure. Taking Colin Farrell under his wing, the two make a great team and are at the heart of a likeable cast in S.W.A.T.
The film continues as the new S.W.A.T. team takes on live challenges in their roles as officers. A romantic spark beings to develop between Rodriguez and Farrell as the team begins to bond. The romantic element works for two reasons: Firstly, the woman comes off as strong a team member as the man does, and secondly, it is not at all the focus of the plot, more like a footnote instead. All the while a new mafia boss has entered town to mark his territory. After mercilessly killing a local mob boss, Alex Montel (played by Oliver Martinez, best known for his roll in Unfaithful) is ironically pulled over for a broken taillight, which translates into his subsequent arrest upon the police’s discovery of his identity. In an attempt to move him to a higher security facility, all hell breaks loose as Montel attempts to escape. The S.W.A.T. team intervenes and thwarts the escape attempt, but not before a live news camera gets in his face for him to deliver a fantastic plot twist: ‘Help me escape, and I’ll pay you $100 million.’ The media is exploited, and now the movie really gets going.

Not only does the multi million dollar offer create a sense of mistrust in the public, but in the police force as well. In one attempt to move the prisoner, a gang attempts to free Montel which turns into a spectacular fire-fight. Montel even attempts to seduce police offers into accepting his bribe, creating a sense of second-guessing all of the characters. When one of the members of the S.W.A.T. team finally takes him up on the offer, the movie begins its push towards the climax.
S.W.A.T. marked the directed debut for one Clarck Johnson, a man who’s had extensive experience in television direction (hit shows such as The Shield and The West Wing). Using a script from writers David Ayer and David McKenna (who between them have a resume of American History X, Training Day, and The Fast and the Furious) the new director was able to create a fun summer action flick. There are so many things that impressed me with his style, which begins with his direction of action sequences. So many directors in action movies today use too many cuts to show sequences unfold, making the audience feel motion sickness. Johnson on the other hand uses longer cuts and uses the camera to give good coverage of the action spots. Also, as in Bad Boys II, these type of action movies easily become lude in the demeanour of the character’s dialogue and actions. In S.W.A.T. the characters keep it clean enough so that you wouldn’t be embarrassed to watch it with your parents, and thus create a likeable ensemble cast. This was an applaudable effort from this new director, and I look forward to seeing his next work.

Video
While I’m afraid I can’t compare this transfer to the one initially released, it’s a fair assessment to make that it’s an improvement being that there are no extras on this disc compared to the other release, which was loaded with them. Filmed in a 2:40:1 aspect ratio, the video transfer for S.W.A.T. in its Superbit release has a technical quality of near perfection: there’s no haloing as a result from edge enhancement, nor is there film grain prevalent during the film. Dark colours are well balanced against each other allowing for various shades to be projected clearly differentiated from each other. At times the colours look wonderful showing flashes of brilliance particularly in action sequences in the street action sequences and during the finally on the railroad tracks (where white lights are shown shining through fog at night, without error).
Despite it’s achievements in the aforementioned technical arenas, I felt somewhat let down in this video transfer especially with the consistency of certain colours. For example, the dark blue jumpsuits that the S.W.A.T. team wears sometimes would change from a rich colour to a dull colour in the same scene (in-between edit cuts). The colours don’t constantly jump off the screen at you like they do in other Superbit titles such as Bad Boys II and Once Upon a Time in Mexico. The director’s choice of using video camera ‘news’ footage split throughout the film for narration purposes also makes S.W.A.T. lose points, as it caused pixilation at times because of it’s low quality. This transfer is by no means a bad one and is sound in many aspects, but I feel as though it could have been better.

Audio
Presented in both Dolby Digital and DTS, it’s the audio portion of this Superbit that really shines. While many action films have the opportunity to have an impressive audio track, S.W.A.T. benefits from a creative sound design. A variety of different gunshot sounds mix things up on the action sequences in the process keeping them from being redundant. All sound channels are used throughout the movie, even in non action scenes, to create engulfing environments. One of the better examples of this is in the police station when you can hear a baby crying in one channel, a phone ringing in another, chatter all over the place, with the main dialogue still being heard clearly. The filtering of voices is another technique that the sound designer used effectively giving scenes a sense of realism.
The audio portion of S.W.A.T. also accentuates a glowing music soundtrack. While the score wasn’t something that really blew me away, the clarity of the music is nothing short of stellar. Bass sounds aren’t overbearing and high brass sounds ring amazingly clear. The dialogue is never drowned out by the other sound elements, which makes the S.W.A.T. Superbit a superb audio presentation.
Extras
As always with Superbit titles, S.W.A.T. includes no extra features. Just in case you were unaware, this is done intentionally so that compression can be kept to a minimum to increase the video and sound quality of the feature presentation.

Overall
I am very pleased to report that S.W.A.T. caught me by surprise; I expected a hollow action film with crass dialogue, and instead was treated to a fun popcorn- movie. A likeable cast led by Colin Farrell and Samuel L. Jackson allow the audience to be attached to the characters and feel at least some kind of emotion during their dynamic scenes. This is not your run of the mill brainless action flick, but its plot won’t give you a headache to thinking about it either. Even though Columbia Tri-Star has given a decent effort in the Superbit edition, I’d recommend checking out the previously released S.W.A.T. Special Edition which is packed with extras. That is certainly my plan. If you already own the DVD from the previous release, this probably isn't a big enough improvement to warrant a double-dip.
Review by Brian R

Film
The movie opens with a great hook for an action movie: members of a S.W.A.T. team in Los Angeles are in the middle of a rescue situation. The team succeeds, but injures a civilian in the process. This causes officer Brian Gamble (Jeremy Renner) to quit, and also sees Jim Street (Colin Farrel) get demoted. A rift between the two former best friends and partners forms as they go their separate ways. Fast-forward five months where veteran Sgt. Hondo Harrelson (played by bona fide bad-ass Samuel L. Jackson) is given the assignment of assembling a new S.W.A.T. team. He enlists the help of Farrell’s character to also recruit officers played by Michelle Rodriguez, LL Cool J, and Josh Charles to formulate the new team for the L.A. Police Department. There are some fun training sequences here, including a poker game in which card hands are obtained by using sniper rifles to hit their cards. The final test for this group to become an activated S.W.A.T. unit occurs in a mock terrorist situation on an airplane. These training sequences are engaging because we get to learn about our heroes throughout the duration of them. This important detail will make the real action sequences better and more meaningful. Samuel L. Jackson (best known for his role in Pulp Fiction) is wonderful in his role as a mentor to the rest of his team, trying to keep things cool under pressure. Taking Colin Farrell under his wing, the two make a great team and are at the heart of a likeable cast in S.W.A.T.
The film continues as the new S.W.A.T. team takes on live challenges in their roles as officers. A romantic spark beings to develop between Rodriguez and Farrell as the team begins to bond. The romantic element works for two reasons: Firstly, the woman comes off as strong a team member as the man does, and secondly, it is not at all the focus of the plot, more like a footnote instead. All the while a new mafia boss has entered town to mark his territory. After mercilessly killing a local mob boss, Alex Montel (played by Oliver Martinez, best known for his roll in Unfaithful) is ironically pulled over for a broken taillight, which translates into his subsequent arrest upon the police’s discovery of his identity. In an attempt to move him to a higher security facility, all hell breaks loose as Montel attempts to escape. The S.W.A.T. team intervenes and thwarts the escape attempt, but not before a live news camera gets in his face for him to deliver a fantastic plot twist: ‘Help me escape, and I’ll pay you $100 million.’ The media is exploited, and now the movie really gets going.

Not only does the multi million dollar offer create a sense of mistrust in the public, but in the police force as well. In one attempt to move the prisoner, a gang attempts to free Montel which turns into a spectacular fire-fight. Montel even attempts to seduce police offers into accepting his bribe, creating a sense of second-guessing all of the characters. When one of the members of the S.W.A.T. team finally takes him up on the offer, the movie begins its push towards the climax.
S.W.A.T. marked the directed debut for one Clarck Johnson, a man who’s had extensive experience in television direction (hit shows such as The Shield and The West Wing). Using a script from writers David Ayer and David McKenna (who between them have a resume of American History X, Training Day, and The Fast and the Furious) the new director was able to create a fun summer action flick. There are so many things that impressed me with his style, which begins with his direction of action sequences. So many directors in action movies today use too many cuts to show sequences unfold, making the audience feel motion sickness. Johnson on the other hand uses longer cuts and uses the camera to give good coverage of the action spots. Also, as in Bad Boys II, these type of action movies easily become lude in the demeanour of the character’s dialogue and actions. In S.W.A.T. the characters keep it clean enough so that you wouldn’t be embarrassed to watch it with your parents, and thus create a likeable ensemble cast. This was an applaudable effort from this new director, and I look forward to seeing his next work.

Video
While I’m afraid I can’t compare this transfer to the one initially released, it’s a fair assessment to make that it’s an improvement being that there are no extras on this disc compared to the other release, which was loaded with them. Filmed in a 2:40:1 aspect ratio, the video transfer for S.W.A.T. in its Superbit release has a technical quality of near perfection: there’s no haloing as a result from edge enhancement, nor is there film grain prevalent during the film. Dark colours are well balanced against each other allowing for various shades to be projected clearly differentiated from each other. At times the colours look wonderful showing flashes of brilliance particularly in action sequences in the street action sequences and during the finally on the railroad tracks (where white lights are shown shining through fog at night, without error).
Despite it’s achievements in the aforementioned technical arenas, I felt somewhat let down in this video transfer especially with the consistency of certain colours. For example, the dark blue jumpsuits that the S.W.A.T. team wears sometimes would change from a rich colour to a dull colour in the same scene (in-between edit cuts). The colours don’t constantly jump off the screen at you like they do in other Superbit titles such as Bad Boys II and Once Upon a Time in Mexico. The director’s choice of using video camera ‘news’ footage split throughout the film for narration purposes also makes S.W.A.T. lose points, as it caused pixilation at times because of it’s low quality. This transfer is by no means a bad one and is sound in many aspects, but I feel as though it could have been better.

Audio
Presented in both Dolby Digital and DTS, it’s the audio portion of this Superbit that really shines. While many action films have the opportunity to have an impressive audio track, S.W.A.T. benefits from a creative sound design. A variety of different gunshot sounds mix things up on the action sequences in the process keeping them from being redundant. All sound channels are used throughout the movie, even in non action scenes, to create engulfing environments. One of the better examples of this is in the police station when you can hear a baby crying in one channel, a phone ringing in another, chatter all over the place, with the main dialogue still being heard clearly. The filtering of voices is another technique that the sound designer used effectively giving scenes a sense of realism.
The audio portion of S.W.A.T. also accentuates a glowing music soundtrack. While the score wasn’t something that really blew me away, the clarity of the music is nothing short of stellar. Bass sounds aren’t overbearing and high brass sounds ring amazingly clear. The dialogue is never drowned out by the other sound elements, which makes the S.W.A.T. Superbit a superb audio presentation.
Extras
As always with Superbit titles, S.W.A.T. includes no extra features. Just in case you were unaware, this is done intentionally so that compression can be kept to a minimum to increase the video and sound quality of the feature presentation.

Overall
I am very pleased to report that S.W.A.T. caught me by surprise; I expected a hollow action film with crass dialogue, and instead was treated to a fun popcorn- movie. A likeable cast led by Colin Farrell and Samuel L. Jackson allow the audience to be attached to the characters and feel at least some kind of emotion during their dynamic scenes. This is not your run of the mill brainless action flick, but its plot won’t give you a headache to thinking about it either. Even though Columbia Tri-Star has given a decent effort in the Superbit edition, I’d recommend checking out the previously released S.W.A.T. Special Edition which is packed with extras. That is certainly my plan. If you already own the DVD from the previous release, this probably isn't a big enough improvement to warrant a double-dip.
Review by Brian R
Advertisement
Matt
Contributor
Join Date: October 2004
Location: United States
Posts: 1,968
Columbia's Superbit DVDs
I'm convinced that these are a total marketing ploy from Columbia, there isn't any reason that these are not the transfers packed in the normal release of the DVD and its just a way for Columbia to fleece consumers by forcing them to either choose between a quality transfer and extras or purchasing both the standard and Superbit editions to get the best overall package.
Report
Quote
| Reply
That's a valid point Matt. There have been some rumblings that the regular release of Spider-Man 2 was dulled down a bit to drive a market for its Superbit counterpart. While that remains a mystery, it's still a thought. When you look at all the different features on a movie disc though, such as intricate menus, multiple commentaries, multiple soundtracks, subtitles, and even some special features, it cannot be ignored that those things do take up space.
All of the Superbits that I have seen have been the first time I've seen that particular movie, so it's tough for me to gauge an accurate opinion. I will say that the idea behind them is very fan oriented, in that they are specifically for fans of the movie that want the best possible picture and sound quality. I just don't see why they have to be so damned expensive.
All of the Superbits that I have seen have been the first time I've seen that particular movie, so it's tough for me to gauge an accurate opinion. I will say that the idea behind them is very fan oriented, in that they are specifically for fans of the movie that want the best possible picture and sound quality. I just don't see why they have to be so damned expensive.
I recently reviewed both versions of Spider-Man 2, and with that set in particular there was no reason that the Superbit transfer couldn't have been packaged in the standard release; other studios are giving consumers both quality transfers and special features without asking them to choose.
The SM2 Superbit transfer comes in at 5.7 GB and with its DD and DTS tracks the size of the total film comes to around 6.7 GB total. There is over 2.0 GB of empty space on the SM2 Superbit DVD (far less than what they claim to utilize in their advertising), and I would assume given its runtime that S.W.A.T. is nearly identical to those specs. Most commentaries are about 100-120 MB in size, menus are generally very small and subtitles are only a few kilobytes in size so there would still be over 1.5 GB of empty space on the disc.
The standard Spider-Man 2 release could have moved all of the extrenuous trailers and one or two of the other extras on disc one over to disc two and there would have been plenty of room left over to place the Superbit transfer in the set. I rated those sets as a 6/10(SB) and a 7/10(SW), but a set having both, like other studios' releases give you, would have gotten that package an 8/10 or 9/10. I think it would be interesting and enlightening to some folks to compare more of these Superbit titles side-by-side with their standard release counterparts.
Sorry about the rant, I just hate it when I think people are getting unknowingly short changed when it comes to their DVDs.
The SM2 Superbit transfer comes in at 5.7 GB and with its DD and DTS tracks the size of the total film comes to around 6.7 GB total. There is over 2.0 GB of empty space on the SM2 Superbit DVD (far less than what they claim to utilize in their advertising), and I would assume given its runtime that S.W.A.T. is nearly identical to those specs. Most commentaries are about 100-120 MB in size, menus are generally very small and subtitles are only a few kilobytes in size so there would still be over 1.5 GB of empty space on the disc.
The standard Spider-Man 2 release could have moved all of the extrenuous trailers and one or two of the other extras on disc one over to disc two and there would have been plenty of room left over to place the Superbit transfer in the set. I rated those sets as a 6/10(SB) and a 7/10(SW), but a set having both, like other studios' releases give you, would have gotten that package an 8/10 or 9/10. I think it would be interesting and enlightening to some folks to compare more of these Superbit titles side-by-side with their standard release counterparts.
Sorry about the rant, I just hate it when I think people are getting unknowingly short changed when it comes to their DVDs.
No worries at all.
I wonder what will happen when the next format comes out with a significantly larger memory capability - will they actually give us the best transfer straight away or think of some other way to promote a newer 'high definition transfer and sound'....
Good question. The distributors will have to be a bit creative to do something like the Superbit series in the next format wave.
eh
I don't hate superbit. I'm not a bonus material man anyway.
The only bonus material i really enjoy is extensive documentaires *such as the 4 disk pearl harbor dvd* and indepth commentairs, i love commentaries. And on top of that I really have to love the movie to sit through the features. Therefore buying a superbit movie for $20 over a feature filled $20 has never bothered me...unless it's a movie i really like.
Such as i already own Cliffhanger on dvd and I like the features, but I just can't get myself to spend another $20, even if it does include that great DTS track...sorry Columbia :\
The only bonus material i really enjoy is extensive documentaires *such as the 4 disk pearl harbor dvd* and indepth commentairs, i love commentaries. And on top of that I really have to love the movie to sit through the features. Therefore buying a superbit movie for $20 over a feature filled $20 has never bothered me...unless it's a movie i really like.
Such as i already own Cliffhanger on dvd and I like the features, but I just can't get myself to spend another $20, even if it does include that great DTS track...sorry Columbia :\


Some material may be inappropriate for children under 13
Disc Details
Release Date:
26th October 2004
Discs:
1
Disc Type:
Single side, dual layer
RCE:
No
Video:
NTSC
Aspect:
2.40:1
Anamorphic:
Yes
Colour:
Yes
Audio:
Dolby Digital 5.1 English, DTS 5.1 English
Subtitles:
English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Korean, Thai
Extras:
None
Easter Egg:
No
Feature Details
Director:
Clarck Johnson
Cast:
Samuel L. Jackson, Colin Farrell, LL Cool J, Michelle Rodriguez, Josh Charles, Jeremy Renner, Oliver Martinez, Brian Van Holt
Genre:
Action
Length:
117 minutes


