Speed Racer (US - BD)
Reviewer Marcus Doidge revs up with Speed Racer on Warner's Blu-ray Disc
Feature
The Wachowskis are back! After those dodgy Matrix sequels and their hand in the fantastic V For Vendetta the Wachowskis bring us their newest visual delight, Speed Racer, telling the story of the Racer family, who have racing in their blood. Speed Racer (Emile Hirsch), the latest son of the Racer family to have a natural talent for racing, is on the verge of hitting the big time on the racing circuit—just how many more references to racing can I fit into that paragraph? Phew!

With the death of the eldest Racer son, Rex (Scott Porter), in the Casa Cristo 5000, an incredibly intense cross-country racing rally that's notorious for rough and foul play, the Racer family are broken. Pops (John Goodman) is full of regret for kicking his son out of the family home days before and the whole family still live under the shadow of the many slanderous stories that came out about Rex in regards to his apparent shady dealings in the corrupt side of racing.
After almost beating his brother’s race record, Speed is approached by Mr. Royalton (Roger Allam), owner of conglomerate Royalton Industries, who wants Speed to race for him under his banner. Speed declines and Royalton turns nasty, explaining how racing is not about winning or losing but about money and corruption. Because Speed has turned down his offer, Royalton sets out to ruin him and his family. Enter Racer X (Matthew Fox) and the character with the coolest name of the year, Inspector Detector (Benno Fürmann) who assure the Racer family that they are aware of the corruption in racing and the only way to bring this system down is by revealing the truth… which Speed can help them with by entering a series of races leading up to the Grand Prix.

2008 was the year in which a number of directors seemed to be given free rein to play in the toy box. Nolan blew a hole in the movie world with The Dark Knight, del Toro seemed to bring his entire toy collection to Hellboy 2 and the Wachowskis got to go anime crazy with Speed Racer. I’ll admit, when I heard the Wachowskis where doing Speed Racer I was underwhelmed. I have no fond memories of the original TV show and to say I was disappointed with the much hyped Wachowski car chase in The Matrix Reloaded is an understatement. I just wrote Speed Racer off to be little more than a mixture of slow motion, bullet time and stop/start action that would be about as kinetic as watching glue drip down a wall. Well thankfully, I was very, very wrong.
From the outset Speed Racer is mesmerising. Those cars fly round those crazy tracks with equal amounts of insanity and grace. The editing is edge of your seat stuff and just when you think it's got as crazy as it can get, it goes even further. This isn’t the dreary showing off that the Matrix car chase suffered from at all, this is something exciting, something new, something spectacular. This has the feeling of playing with toy cars when you were a kid and frankly that comes with full on giddy excitement.

Of course all this flashy stuff would be nothing without some characters to back it up and in this department, once again, Speed Racer shines. The Racer family feel like a real family, with real love for one another and considering this is based on a kids’ TV show and is made for kids, the Wachowskis never shy away from the harsh reality that families can come with problems and the Racer family have a lot of them. At the core of all this, the death of Rex Racer is really what’s stopping this family from being happy. Despite looking as if they’d moved on and got back into the racing game, Rex’s death is holding them all back, especially Speed. He’s better than his brother but he doesn’t want to take that legacy away. This is captured almost immediately in the opening fifteen minutes, which show Speed on the brink of beating his brother’s record. Inter-cut with flashbacks of a younger Speed learning to drive alongside Rex and the Wachowskis doing a fine job of showing how he idolised him and had childhood dreams of being just like him. You really get how much the family miss Rex with the open scene playing out and thankfully it’s not rammed down your throat but just under the surface.
What follows this killer opening sequence is a forty minutes change of pace which I’d imagine is what some of the negative reviews the movie received stem from. There are still a great deal of cool visuals, but it all becomes about setting up the rest of the movie and just gets a little heavy in places, especially for the kids the film was made for. One scene in particular bangs on about the history of racing, its corruption and how it affected the stock market, and I for one know that my kids didn’t follow any of it, other than they knew for sure that Mr Royalton was obviously the bad guy at this stage. Also featured a lot in this run of the movie, is the other factor to split the audience down the middle: the youngest member of the Racer family, Spritle and his Chimp. I personally think they're fairly well handled and never annoyed me too much, but I can see how the kid might. Saying that though, it’s worth having the chimp in it for the shot of the family standing hands on hips annoyed with Speed and having the chimp in the same stance. Made me chuckle anyway.

The lull soon lifts, with the arrival of Racer X. As soon as he meets up with the family and enters into the races alongside Speed, the movie just gets great again. Matthew Fox has a close to God-like status in my household, due to the huge amount of love we all have for Lost (in fact my three year old proclaimed ‘Jack from Lost’ out loud when Racer X de-masked, at the cinema screening) so it was a joy to see him in a role that really got him playing on his strengths. Racer X is cool. Everything he says comes with intensity and the Wachowskis have a field day making him a badass. His fight scene with the ninja is the Wachowskis at their Matrix best, and Racer X’s input when helping Speed in the Casa Cristo 5000 (yes, Speed goes to race where his brother died!) is ridiculously cool and added to that, the 'is he, isn’t he' Speed’s brother Rex back from the dead mystery (which I won’t ruin for you) is beautifully played out.
At its core, Speed Racer is a sports movie. It’s more subtle than you’d think and it really comes into play in the final Grand Prix. The moment Speed Racer steps out on that track, you genuinely get a feeling that this is building to something and amazingly it really does. The last race is like the podrace from the Phantom Menace, but on lots and lots of drugs, the Wachowskis throw the kitchen sink at you on this one. Every single moment is incredible and like every classic sports movie finale, every element that this moment is riding on is included. The Racer family, the bad guys, Racer X, it all seems to come down to this race. The insanity builds, the emotional punch is woven in beautifully, the editing gets frantic, the visuals just blow your mind to the point where you are almost re-experiencing the end of 2001: A Space Odyssey and you are literally caught in moment of absolute movie gold.

I won’t spoil the end for you but I will say that I came out the other end of this Blu-ray, as hyped and as impressed as I was the first time I saw it on the cinema screen. Yes, it might be a little long in places and yes, some viewers might need to persevere more than others, but for me, Speed Racer kicked off the 2008 Summer movie season with a bang and I’m glad to say I was still feeling the aftershocks on this Blu-ray release.
Video
From very early on, this was a Blu-ray that I was looking forward to getting. From the very first trailer this screamed ‘see me in HD’ and it does not disappoint. Speed Racer glows in solid neon off of the screen for the most part and then everything else is the purest use of primary colours I’ve seen in a long time, in fact the colours on my TV have never been used to such full effect. The speed of the images never have a problem keeping their detail and aside from some minor issues with patchy darker scenes, it has to be said that this is a transfer that really has to be considered a show-off Blu-ray, mainly to experience how much is going on. From its use of light, colour, detail and sheer experimentation within the image, Speed Racer just keeps on out-doing itself as the movie progresses until you get to that dizzying closing race that takes it out of this world.

Audio
Presented in plain ol’ Dolby Digital 5.1, this manages to do a pretty good job, considering you would expect more sound options from an HD release. The surround is well thought out within the 5.1 system, with sounds of cars everywhere, a great amount of bass for the soundtrack and generally clear dialogue. I say generally, as there's a slightly bizarre echo to some of the dialogue within some of the cars' cockpits. It’s ever so slight and more than likely intentional, but I never noticed it in the cinema, so felt it needed mentioning here.
I did feel that the sound could have used just a little bit more oomph in places. The first half, where I really focused on it for the good of this review, I certainly felt it needed something a bit more powerful, but by movies end and in the big climatic final race, it all kicks in wonderfully. Strong bass, great atmospheric use of all the speakers and overall it really delivers the goods.

Extras
Now this is where Speed Racer really lets itself down. Considering the technical wizardry involved in this movie we get pretty close to nothing. There’s a making of called ‘Car Fu’ (27:38), which gives you the briefest of stories on how the Wachowskis came about doing the project, though not from the brothers themselves, but from Joel Silver and some of the SFX guys. There are some animatics and discussions on the work that went into the movie, but this all moves along lightning fast and despite it covering all the bases it’s hardly in the detail the movie deserves.
Next up, is following the kid with the chimp around, in ‘Spritle in the Big Leagues’ (14:34), which is actually okay in regards to detail with the pop up facts throughout, but it’s really glossy nonsense at best. Same can be said for ‘Speed Racer: Super Charged’ (15:43), a featurette in which we meet the drivers, the cars and the tracks. It’s really not that enthralling.
To add insult to injury, disc two is a DVD based Speed Racer game, which is interactive, slow and the pausing between selections was infuriating. This might hold your attention for around five minutes but if it goes beyond that you may want to seek medical assistance.
To round up there’s a digital copy on disc three that, depending on your feelings on this sort of thing, is a either a nice bonus or a waste of time.

Overall
I enjoyed Speed Racer immensely when it kicked off summer 2008’s big movies and I enjoyed it even more on Blu-ray. It’s full of incredible visuals, it’s a lot of fun and even more than all of that, it has a whole lot of heart.
Fans of sports movies should eat this up as it does everything sports movies should do, and with genuine class and anyone who's really up for seeing something new and exciting should also get a kick out of it too. I’m not blinded by my admiration for the movie to recommend this to everyone—it’s a pretty hard sell for anyone going into this one blind or not wanting to like it—but don’t let its poor take at the box office put you off. Speed Racer has a lot to entertain and despite its poor special features and it’s one hell of an impressive Blu-ray release that I will be watching a whole lot.
* Note: The images on this page are not representative of the Blu-ray release.
Review by Marcus Doidge
Advertisements
Existing Posts
I still can't believe a movie of this caliber has been released with just plain old 5.1!
Shame, studios, shame!
I wonder if region B gets the better sound options?
Shame, studios, shame!
I wonder if region B gets the better sound options?
For some reason I didn't like it. I admit it was fun at times but for 2 1/2 hours it was seriously boring. The dark knight was good and it was 2 1/2 hours and shoot even King Kong was fantastic and that was 3 hours!
I wanted to see what the effects were like. The story was so badly told that I couldn't stand it anymore. Then there was the monkey........I'd seen the effects, I didn't care about the story so I turned it off.
Sorry, I just wasn't gonna like it. I didn't say it was bad and I'm glad you enjoyed it, but 'I' didn't like it.
Sorry, I just wasn't gonna like it. I didn't say it was bad and I'm glad you enjoyed it, but 'I' didn't like it.
Tricky Dicky wrote: I turned it off after 15 mins. I saw all I needed to see. i cant stand you people you do know the movie may actaully get better in 15 min ill agree the first hr is kinda slow the movie gets alot better When Racer X hits the sceen i loved the movie perhaps you should try watchin the whole movie. anyway id giive this a 8/10
I turned it off after 15 mins. I saw all I needed to see.
Let me say this first, the review of the movie was GREAT, I hate people who b***h about reviews.
I love Speed Racer, this is the first of many anticipated BR's in the coming months. It is not often I get a movie at Midnight, I can usually hold out till the Tuesday afternoon to get it, but I waited and hour after my shift at work was done to go get this so I could watch it last night at 12:30. Let me say it looks AMAZING on BR. I love everything about this movie, the look just knocks my socks off. I am going to watch it again in a bit because it is just a cool movie.
I love Speed Racer, this is the first of many anticipated BR's in the coming months. It is not often I get a movie at Midnight, I can usually hold out till the Tuesday afternoon to get it, but I waited and hour after my shift at work was done to go get this so I could watch it last night at 12:30. Let me say it looks AMAZING on BR. I love everything about this movie, the look just knocks my socks off. I am going to watch it again in a bit because it is just a cool movie.
Saw this on IMAX. LOVED IT! Very good movie. Sad that people didn't see it...
The reviewers on this site do a great job. Leave em be. You can see that they all have a fun time doing so. The reviews simply add to the wonderful DVD news.I love this site!
Disciple wrote: Ah common', enough with this already!
Marcus wrote a wonderful review. These people are doing this for free and they're very good at it. Quit complaining and read the whole review not just the A/V sections!
Why do you need to compare? So you can tell whoever wrote the review you thought was worst that they're bad at what they're doing? What good comes from that?
I'm not trying to demean anybody. I just want to see if Gabe was rigt is saying that he himself was s**t when he started out.
Marcus wrote a wonderful review. These people are doing this for free and they're very good at it. Quit complaining and read the whole review not just the A/V sections!
Why do you need to compare? So you can tell whoever wrote the review you thought was worst that they're bad at what they're doing? What good comes from that?
I'm not trying to demean anybody. I just want to see if Gabe was rigt is saying that he himself was s**t when he started out.
Ah common', enough with this already!
Marcus wrote a wonderful review. These people are doing this for free and they're very good at it. Quit complaining and read the whole review not just the A/V sections!
Why do you need to compare? So you can tell whoever wrote the review you thought was worst that they're bad at what they're doing? What good comes from that?
Marcus wrote a wonderful review. These people are doing this for free and they're very good at it. Quit complaining and read the whole review not just the A/V sections!
Why do you need to compare? So you can tell whoever wrote the review you thought was worst that they're bad at what they're doing? What good comes from that?
Gabe Powers wrote: Anyone comparing my writing to Marcus' need only look at my early reviews. I was s**t. Marcus is already ahead of the curve her, and he just started.
So we I can compare, what were some of your first review Gabe?
So we I can compare, what were some of your first review Gabe?
Completely agree with this review. SRs a very fun film. I'll be picking it up shortly.
Anyone comparing my writing to Marcus' need only look at my early reviews. I was s**t. Marcus is already ahead of the curve her, and he just started.
A near masterpiece in my eyes. The BD is gorgeous, it's just a shame about the audio.
How much of that review is technical and how much is filler? He says the same thing about three times. Same with the DVDbeaver review. It contains no more technical info than Marcus gives in this review, it just has screen caps.
Sorry Chris, ment Gabe (temporary brain melt). And yes, here we go again. Sorry for having an opinion, but this is why I come to dedicated DVD sites, to read reviews. As you can see, I generally don't post, because I get what I come for, great reviews of audio & video quality. I was expecting something a little more thorough on a title this anticipated. Something like this from Bill @ Digital Bits "The 1080p widescreen video quality is, in a word, spectacular. Yes, you read that right, and I'm not exaggerating either. This transfer is absolutely outstanding. Now, I first saw this film projected digitally in 2K resolution in the Ross Theatre on the Warner back lot, and no screening I saw thereafter EVER came close to that dazzling level of presentation quality. This film is eye-popping in its hues, movement and detail, and it's tailor made for digital presentation. Photochemical film just doesn't do it justice, even in large-format IMAX. And let me tell you, Speed Racer has never looked so good to me since that first digital screening... until I saw this Blu-ray this afternoon. It's just damn near perfect, and I guarantee it's better than anything any of you saw in the theatres. Colors absolutely burst off the screen, contrast is outstanding and detail is spot-on. You're going to notice that some DNR was used here and there - you'll notice it on faces, in particular Mom and Pops Racer - but that's not something that was done for Blu-ray. I noticed it in that original screening. It's a stylistic choice on the part of the filmmakers. But trust me, the detail everywhere else is crisp and exactly as it should be. There is some very light digital compression artifacting here and there, but it's very well hidden by all the fast movement on screen. Trust me, I'm watching this in native 1080p on a 110" screen, and I really had to look for it. Speed Racer is right up there with the best Blu-ray video I've seen yet." Better yet, check out the DVDBeaver's excellent review of the title (with actual Blu-ray screen caps!). I don't want to knock the site, it does a tremendous job of balancing release information and actual reviews, but this review just felt kinda half assed. One man's opinion.
Who is Peter? No one called peter has reviewed for the site in years, and never in the US.
The Vendetta wrote: I haven't gotten around to seeing this movie, but I'm pretty sure Iron Man was the big bang that kicked off the 2008 Summer movie season, since it came out a week before Speed Racer.
That's actually a very good point. I thought it was the other way round but you are indeed correct.
I guess its because I was pretty underwhelmed with Iron Man that I remembered Speed Racer really starting the summer movie fun. hehe
That's actually a very good point. I thought it was the other way round but you are indeed correct.
I guess its because I was pretty underwhelmed with Iron Man that I remembered Speed Racer really starting the summer movie fun. hehe
sandwich wrote: Maybe it's just me, but I thought that review was incredibley awkward. Summarize the film, fine, do your thing. But in my opinion, the Audio & Video sections of the review sounded like someone trying to write, but not actually knowing, what makes for a good transfer or audio track. There are many people who have been waiting for this disc, anticipating that it will be "THE" transfer of the year in terms of flat out "you gotta buy a Blu-ray player" bravado. This review just told me that it had bright colors and that there were some problems in the "dark scenes". Thanks...........In the future can we ensure that Peter review the "big" releases so we at least get a balanced review with actual information on the technical merits of a release. Sorry if it sounds negative, but this review should have got me excited, and it didn't.
Here we go again...
Here we go again...
We may have multiple reviews of the big releases, so keep an eye out for one with maybe a little more technical information.
In case i didn't make it clear, I'd say it has moments of being the stunning transfer we all wanted from it, but it's not quite as good as I'd hoped it would be overall. (as per the 9/10 rather than the full 10) I mentioned the colours a lot in the review because that was the element that really struck me as making good use of the Blu- ray transfer and are the big thing in what makes this movie so striking.
In case i didn't make it clear, I'd say it has moments of being the stunning transfer we all wanted from it, but it's not quite as good as I'd hoped it would be overall. (as per the 9/10 rather than the full 10) I mentioned the colours a lot in the review because that was the element that really struck me as making good use of the Blu- ray transfer and are the big thing in what makes this movie so striking.
Maybe it's just me, but I thought that review was incredibley awkward. Summarize the film, fine, do your thing. But in my opinion, the Audio & Video sections of the review sounded like someone trying to write, but not actually knowing, what makes for a good transfer or audio track. There are many people who have been waiting for this disc, anticipating that it will be "THE" transfer of the year in terms of flat out "you gotta buy a Blu-ray player" bravado. This review just told me that it had bright colors and that there were some problems in the "dark scenes". Thanks...........In the future can we ensure that Peter review the "big" releases so we at least get a balanced review with actual information on the technical merits of a release. Sorry if it sounds negative, but this review should have got me excited, and it didn't.
I haven't gotten around to seeing this movie, but I'm pretty sure Iron Man was the big bang that kicked off the 2008 Summer movie season, since it came out a week before Speed Racer.
Why would the word s-p-a-s-t-i-c be censored? Is that a naughty word in some other language?
Chris Gould wrote: Think I'll trust the opinions of those who have seen it and check it out. Kermode liked it, so it can't be all bad.
Never trust someone named after a toilet
Never trust someone named after a toilet
Chris Gould wrote: Think I'll trust the opinions of those who have seen it and check it out.
I saw this and I didn't enjoy it at all. Fancy-schmancy CGI a good movie does not make. This movie was like a s*****c seizure waiting to happen. In between the shiny bright colors was a plot so thin that you'd have to measure it in nanometers. By the way, my son hated this movie so much he asked if we could leave the movie theater about half-way through it.
I saw this and I didn't enjoy it at all. Fancy-schmancy CGI a good movie does not make. This movie was like a s*****c seizure waiting to happen. In between the shiny bright colors was a plot so thin that you'd have to measure it in nanometers. By the way, my son hated this movie so much he asked if we could leave the movie theater about half-way through it.
this was my favorite movie of the summer. it made me feel like i was 10 years old again. its fun, visually thrilling and surprisingly emotional. i loved it and cant wait to pick it up on tuesday.
I really regret missing this one in theaters. Tsk.
knight d wrote: I have been waiting to see this again since the day it came out. I meant to see it in IMAX but never got the chance. Hopefully I'll enjoy the blu ray as much even though the other discs are pointless. Digital Copy? No thanks.
Let's hope WB doesn't do this with The Dark Knight. That is definetly not something I want to be watching on my iPod. Even the regular cinema screens are too small for The Dark Knight. I suggest they start getting creative with all that extra disc space blu ray offers.
Maybe I just don't understand what people get out of there digital copies. Speed Racer is also the first movie of the year I actually want to purchase. It is that awesome.
I'd say that as well, but The Bank Job was good enough to purchase (for me).
Let's hope WB doesn't do this with The Dark Knight. That is definetly not something I want to be watching on my iPod. Even the regular cinema screens are too small for The Dark Knight. I suggest they start getting creative with all that extra disc space blu ray offers.
Maybe I just don't understand what people get out of there digital copies. Speed Racer is also the first movie of the year I actually want to purchase. It is that awesome.
I'd say that as well, but The Bank Job was good enough to purchase (for me).
I have been waiting to see this again since the day it came out. I meant to see it in IMAX but never got the chance. Hopefully I'll enjoy the blu ray as much even though the other discs are pointless. Digital Copy? No thanks.
Let's hope WB doesn't do this with The Dark Knight. That is definetly not something I want to be watching on my iPod. Even the regular cinema screens are too small for The Dark Knight. I suggest they start getting creative with all that extra disc space blu ray offers.
Maybe I just don't understand what people get out of there digital copies. Speed Racer is also the first movie of the year I actually want to purchase. It is that awesome.
Let's hope WB doesn't do this with The Dark Knight. That is definetly not something I want to be watching on my iPod. Even the regular cinema screens are too small for The Dark Knight. I suggest they start getting creative with all that extra disc space blu ray offers.
Maybe I just don't understand what people get out of there digital copies. Speed Racer is also the first movie of the year I actually want to purchase. It is that awesome.
regarding the lack of extras, its probably due to its financial failure. but considering the kind of movie it is, i'm sure they did film lots of stuff they were intending to be extras but the studio decided not to put them because they're babies.
or........there's a future double dip coming which is likely. lol
or........there's a future double dip coming which is likely. lol
Think I'll trust the opinions of those who have seen it and check it out. Kermode liked it, so it can't be all bad.
This movie looks ridiculous.
Speed Racer is sensory overdrive. I need to see it again just to see what I missed.I agree, the W brothers are definitely back. Very enjoyable movie.
I loved the hell out of this thing. Granted, it is a bit long for a film aimed at kids, but I had a great time watching it. Definitley buying it come Tuesday.
I really, truly loved this movie and it's, in my little-read book, a tremendous injustice that this was the go-to BO bomb of the summer. I'm VERY relieved to read that the video quality doesn't suffer from the decision to make this a BD25, but even though I don't have an audio setup that can take advantage of HD audio formats, it's still a shame Speed got the shaft. But that won't stop me from picking this up on tuesday.
And I think i'm one of the very few people on this site who use the Digital Copy for their PMP, so I'm glad they included it with the BD.
And I think i'm one of the very few people on this site who use the Digital Copy for their PMP, so I'm glad they included it with the BD.
Thanks for a great, though a bit spoilery review Marcus! I'm definitely looking forward to getting this one more than i was before i read your review. Only a day or so before release now.
I wonder if this will come with a TrueHD track on RB...
Well, at least the PQ is reference quality, that's enough for me i guess.
Personally i don't know what i'll use the digital copy for but it's certainly a waste of time, so is the game disc.
I wonder if this will come with a TrueHD track on RB...
Well, at least the PQ is reference quality, that's enough for me i guess.
Personally i don't know what i'll use the digital copy for but it's certainly a waste of time, so is the game disc.
i thought the movie was solid, and it looked awesome on the big screen, cant wait to pick it up on bd


Some material may not be suitable for children
Disc Details
Release Date:
16th September 2008
Discs:
3
Disc Type:
Blu-ray Disc
RCE:
No
Video:
1080p
Aspect:
2.40:1
Anamorphic:
No
Colour:
Yes
Audio:
Dolby Digital 5.1 English, Dollby Digital 5.1 French, Dolby Digital 5.1 Spanish, Dolby Digital 5.1 Portuguese
Subtitles:
English, French, Spanish, Portuguese
Extras:
Making ofs, Featurette, DVD game, Digital Copy
Easter Egg:
No
Feature Details
Director:
Andy Wachowski, Larry Wachowski
Cast:
Emile Hirsch, Christina Ricci, Matthew Fox, John Goodman, Susan Sarandon
Genre:
Action, Adventure, Drama and Family
Length:
135 minutes
Ratings
Amazon.com
FOLLOW DVDACTIVE
Follow our updates
OTHER INTERESTING STUFF
Reviewer Agony





Latest News





Hot News





Most Talked About




