The Dark Knight Rises (US - BD)
Matt takes a look at the new release of The Caped Crusader's latest outing...
Feature
So it all comes down to this, and with The Dark Night Rises writer, director and producer Christopher Nolan looks to cap off what has been so far an electrifying, tour de force series of films that many consider to be the pinnacle of the comic adaptation genre. 2005's Batman Begins was made with all of the special effects and big action set pieces audiences had come to expect from watching such contemporaries as Spider-Man 2 and X-Men 2: X-Men United, but it was also surprisingly more adult and set a new benchmark for what could be expected of such pictures. The ante was upped with The Dark Knight, a sprawling crime saga that took every dark corner of Begins and dialed them all to 11, which resulted in an Oscar-winning picture that broke box office records behind Heath Ledger's searing performance as The Joker. I can only imagine what anyone walking into a showing thought of it if the last Batman picture they'd seen was Joel Shumacher's Batman & Robin. So by my estimation Nolan's Batman is two for two, but how does The Dark Knight Rises stack up along side his previous entries?
It's been eight years since Batman vanished into the night, turning, in that instant, from hero to fugitive. Assuming the blame for the death of D.A. Harvey Dent, the Dark Knight sacrificed everything for what he and Commissioner Gordon both hoped was the greater good. For a time the lie worked, as criminal activity in Gotham City was crushed under the weight of the anti-crime Dent Act. But everything will change with the arrival of a cunning cat burglar with a mysterious agenda. Far more dangerous, however, is the emergence of Bane, a masked terrorist whose ruthless plans for Gotham drive Bruce out of his self-imposed exile. But even if he dons the cape and cowl again Batman may be no match for Bane, an enemy that is also versed in the uses of darkness and theatricality.
My favorite of Nolan's Batman films is still Batman Begins, mainly because it struck a closer tone in it's visual design and story elements to comic source material and the origin story of Bruce Wayne becoming Batman had never really been explored in any of the previous live-action films. With The Dark Knight, Nolan went further into the realm of realism with a film that could stand alongside many of the epic crime dramas of the past, which honestly was a bit of a disappointment for me, but when taken for what it is and not what it isn't it's still nothing short of a great piece of filmmaking. The Dark Knight Rises tries to straddle the line between Begins and Knight, and at times it works, but often the scale of what the story tries to achieve just seems to big for it to handle without coming off as clumsy.
Make no mistake, The Dark Knight Rises is as big and entertaining a technical achievement as blockbusters get with fine acting and plenty of action, but there's a clunkiness to the script that's difficult to ignore. Though admittedly easier to take on a second viewing, the plot is somewhat convoluted and padded, and the repetitive need of the writers for Bruce Wayne to "become Batman again" twice in the same film is the worst culprit, especially since it leads to there being very little actual Batman in his own flick. Another issue is the need to bring things back full circle with The League of Shadows once again threatening Gotham, which is a nice and symmetrical way to wrap things up but also a little too Return of Jedi-ish and expected. The passage of time is also awkwardly handled during the film's later stages, and even though characters explicitly say how much time is going to pass or how much time has passed between point A and point B there is little in the way of visual cues that might have reinforced the timeline. I'd wager that originally a much more elegant story with a League of Shadows backed Joker as the central villain instead of Bane was the plan, but getting anyone involved in the production of these films to admit as much is a long shot.
I do appreciate that The Dark Knight Rises returns somewhat to the visual flair of Begins with Bane's prison and the rebuilt Batcave calling back sets such as The League of Shadows' fortress, The Narrows and Wayne Tower, and the fusion generator turned bomb is as ridiculously enjoyable as the microwave emitter that Ra's al Ghul planned to destroy Gotham with in the previous film. These more outlandish pieces and story elements were something I missed in The Dark Knight, and I'm glad Nolan's final outing with Batman returned to them a bit more.
Though I've enjoyed this trilogy a great deal and see them as a very good series of films, I've never fully embraced Nolan's vision of The Caped Crusader and am glad that someone else will now get a turn in bringing the character's world to the screen. I'm also glad that they, along with the Spider-Man and X-Men films before, have helped skyrocket the genre to the place that is now, a cinematic world where we actually got an Avengers movie this year that was treated as the huge event it deserved to be and not relegated to the Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D like made-for-television movie it could have been if made just several years ago. I just hope that the whoever next takes the helm of Warner's Batman franchise realizes and embraces the fact that being "realistic" is not the same as taking the comic source material seriously and leans more towards what has made the comic endure since it first appeared in 1939. The best Batman film overall is still the animated feature Batman: Mask of the Phantasm, and the recent Rocksteady Batman games iArkham Asylum and Arkham City (all written by that brilliant mastermind Paul Dini) are a couple of other excellent examples of where I'd like the series to continue on from here on out, and if the next Christopher Nolan to come along can accomplish something along those lines it should be something special.
Video
Warner's video presentation of The Dark Knight Rises is exceptional, and though the switching between the pseudo-IMAX 1.78:1 and 2.40:1 aspect ratios can be distracting at first, you quickly fall into a comfort zone and appreciate the fantastic presentation. The IMAX portions--cropped from their native 1.43:1 aspect ratio to fit television screens--look unsurprisingly great with such a high level of detail and depth that you too will wonder why more directors don't opt for this format over 3D. The more traditional 35mm footage, which caused a bit of a problem on the Blu-ray presentation of The Dark Knight, looks great too with especially nice contrast levels and deep, dark blacks. I couldn't really detect any faults with the video that would hinder the presentation such as aliasing or banding, and being a brand new theatrical release the source material used is clean as a whistle. Overall this is a great, reference quality presentation on Blu-ray and the inclusion of the IMAX sourced footage certainly makes it one of the year's best.
Audio
Warner's audio presentation on the disc is every bit as good as, if not better than, the video presentation, and the only real complaint is that I was left wondering how much better a 7.1 track would have been if one were available. So yeah, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track here is good. Featuring a thunderous LFE channel that will quite literally shake anything in the general vicinity that isn't nailed down (I'm speaking from experience here) and a wide ranging sound field that takes full advantage of the surround channels, this track is now the standard for which others can be measured. Sound effects, music and dialogue (even Bane's, which isn't just relegated to the center channel) are all expertly mixed and all get their own moments to shine, and during scenes with large crowds such as the stock market and final battle you'll feel as if you were right smack dab in the middle of everything. Overall this is a great track, and there's really not much more to say other than you should warn your neighbors ahead of time.
Extras
Though I've come to terms with the fact that, yet again, there's no sign of what would presumably be an engaging commentary track from Christopher Nolan included in the extras here, what is included on the second Blu-ray disc of the set is fairly entertaining and informational high definition stuff. First up though is a feature not included on either disc, Warner's The Dark Knight Rises FX HD App, which can be downloaded from iTunes or Google Play and will act as a sort of second screen option for more extras and behind-the-scenes material synced with viewing the film. As of this writing the feature is not yet active, but if it works like similar features--such as the app paired with Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows--it should be a worthwhile extra to download and try out, given that you have a compatible device of course.
The major production featurette, "Ending The Knight", clocks in at right around 70-minutes, and while not as extensive as the recent "Furious Gods" documentary that accompanied Prometheus on that film's 3D Blu-ray presentation, the multi-part feature is pretty great in its own right. Along with pieces focusing on the production (The Prologue: High Altitude Hijacking, Beneath Gotham, Return to the Batcave, Batman vs Bane, The Bat, Armory Accepted, Gameday Destruction, Demolishing a City Street, The Pit, The Chant, The War on Wall Street and Race to the Reactor), you also get profiles on the characters of Bruce Wayne/Batman, Bane and Selina Kyle/Catwoman. Rounding out these are features based on filming in the IMAX format (Shadows & Light in Large Format) and "The End of A Legend", which focuses on the trilogy as a whole and gives many involved with the production of the trilogy a chance to reflect on the experience.
As good the production featurette is though, I really enjoyed "The Batmobile" even more. True, it really isn't an extra that focuses exclusively on The Dark Knight Rises, but it's great trip down memory lane looking back at the various incarnations of Batman's most iconic ride. Featuring the participation of Christopher Nolan, Tim Burton, Joel Shumacher and a host of artists and writers it's an unexpectedly fun hour of Batman nostalgia. The rest of the features are rounded out with theatrical trailers for The Dark Knight Rises, an art gallery (both also on the second disc), and UltraViolet and standard definition copies of the film available through a download code and on the third disc of the set respectively.
Overall
The Dark Knight Rises is a very good capper to Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, and while my preference towards the more comic book oriented aspects of the character and the world in which he inhabits don't exactly jive with Nolan and company's vision, I've enjoyed these films nonetheless. If ranking the trilogy, I'd have to order them best to least (none of these films could be described as worst) in the order in which they were released. Warner Home Video's Blu-ray presentation features an excellent video track coupled with one of the best audio tracks you're likely to find on the format, along with a couple of hours worth of quality extras that leave you wanting a bit more. Overall, this is a definite purchase and should be near the top of your Xmas list.
So it all comes down to this, and with The Dark Night Rises writer, director and producer Christopher Nolan looks to cap off what has been so far an electrifying, tour de force series of films that many consider to be the pinnacle of the comic adaptation genre. 2005's Batman Begins was made with all of the special effects and big action set pieces audiences had come to expect from watching such contemporaries as Spider-Man 2 and X-Men 2: X-Men United, but it was also surprisingly more adult and set a new benchmark for what could be expected of such pictures. The ante was upped with The Dark Knight, a sprawling crime saga that took every dark corner of Begins and dialed them all to 11, which resulted in an Oscar-winning picture that broke box office records behind Heath Ledger's searing performance as The Joker. I can only imagine what anyone walking into a showing thought of it if the last Batman picture they'd seen was Joel Shumacher's Batman & Robin. So by my estimation Nolan's Batman is two for two, but how does The Dark Knight Rises stack up along side his previous entries?
It's been eight years since Batman vanished into the night, turning, in that instant, from hero to fugitive. Assuming the blame for the death of D.A. Harvey Dent, the Dark Knight sacrificed everything for what he and Commissioner Gordon both hoped was the greater good. For a time the lie worked, as criminal activity in Gotham City was crushed under the weight of the anti-crime Dent Act. But everything will change with the arrival of a cunning cat burglar with a mysterious agenda. Far more dangerous, however, is the emergence of Bane, a masked terrorist whose ruthless plans for Gotham drive Bruce out of his self-imposed exile. But even if he dons the cape and cowl again Batman may be no match for Bane, an enemy that is also versed in the uses of darkness and theatricality.
My favorite of Nolan's Batman films is still Batman Begins, mainly because it struck a closer tone in it's visual design and story elements to comic source material and the origin story of Bruce Wayne becoming Batman had never really been explored in any of the previous live-action films. With The Dark Knight, Nolan went further into the realm of realism with a film that could stand alongside many of the epic crime dramas of the past, which honestly was a bit of a disappointment for me, but when taken for what it is and not what it isn't it's still nothing short of a great piece of filmmaking. The Dark Knight Rises tries to straddle the line between Begins and Knight, and at times it works, but often the scale of what the story tries to achieve just seems to big for it to handle without coming off as clumsy.
Make no mistake, The Dark Knight Rises is as big and entertaining a technical achievement as blockbusters get with fine acting and plenty of action, but there's a clunkiness to the script that's difficult to ignore. Though admittedly easier to take on a second viewing, the plot is somewhat convoluted and padded, and the repetitive need of the writers for Bruce Wayne to "become Batman again" twice in the same film is the worst culprit, especially since it leads to there being very little actual Batman in his own flick. Another issue is the need to bring things back full circle with The League of Shadows once again threatening Gotham, which is a nice and symmetrical way to wrap things up but also a little too Return of Jedi-ish and expected. The passage of time is also awkwardly handled during the film's later stages, and even though characters explicitly say how much time is going to pass or how much time has passed between point A and point B there is little in the way of visual cues that might have reinforced the timeline. I'd wager that originally a much more elegant story with a League of Shadows backed Joker as the central villain instead of Bane was the plan, but getting anyone involved in the production of these films to admit as much is a long shot.
I do appreciate that The Dark Knight Rises returns somewhat to the visual flair of Begins with Bane's prison and the rebuilt Batcave calling back sets such as The League of Shadows' fortress, The Narrows and Wayne Tower, and the fusion generator turned bomb is as ridiculously enjoyable as the microwave emitter that Ra's al Ghul planned to destroy Gotham with in the previous film. These more outlandish pieces and story elements were something I missed in The Dark Knight, and I'm glad Nolan's final outing with Batman returned to them a bit more.
Though I've enjoyed this trilogy a great deal and see them as a very good series of films, I've never fully embraced Nolan's vision of The Caped Crusader and am glad that someone else will now get a turn in bringing the character's world to the screen. I'm also glad that they, along with the Spider-Man and X-Men films before, have helped skyrocket the genre to the place that is now, a cinematic world where we actually got an Avengers movie this year that was treated as the huge event it deserved to be and not relegated to the Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D like made-for-television movie it could have been if made just several years ago. I just hope that the whoever next takes the helm of Warner's Batman franchise realizes and embraces the fact that being "realistic" is not the same as taking the comic source material seriously and leans more towards what has made the comic endure since it first appeared in 1939. The best Batman film overall is still the animated feature Batman: Mask of the Phantasm, and the recent Rocksteady Batman games iArkham Asylum and Arkham City (all written by that brilliant mastermind Paul Dini) are a couple of other excellent examples of where I'd like the series to continue on from here on out, and if the next Christopher Nolan to come along can accomplish something along those lines it should be something special.
Video
Warner's video presentation of The Dark Knight Rises is exceptional, and though the switching between the pseudo-IMAX 1.78:1 and 2.40:1 aspect ratios can be distracting at first, you quickly fall into a comfort zone and appreciate the fantastic presentation. The IMAX portions--cropped from their native 1.43:1 aspect ratio to fit television screens--look unsurprisingly great with such a high level of detail and depth that you too will wonder why more directors don't opt for this format over 3D. The more traditional 35mm footage, which caused a bit of a problem on the Blu-ray presentation of The Dark Knight, looks great too with especially nice contrast levels and deep, dark blacks. I couldn't really detect any faults with the video that would hinder the presentation such as aliasing or banding, and being a brand new theatrical release the source material used is clean as a whistle. Overall this is a great, reference quality presentation on Blu-ray and the inclusion of the IMAX sourced footage certainly makes it one of the year's best.
Audio
Warner's audio presentation on the disc is every bit as good as, if not better than, the video presentation, and the only real complaint is that I was left wondering how much better a 7.1 track would have been if one were available. So yeah, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track here is good. Featuring a thunderous LFE channel that will quite literally shake anything in the general vicinity that isn't nailed down (I'm speaking from experience here) and a wide ranging sound field that takes full advantage of the surround channels, this track is now the standard for which others can be measured. Sound effects, music and dialogue (even Bane's, which isn't just relegated to the center channel) are all expertly mixed and all get their own moments to shine, and during scenes with large crowds such as the stock market and final battle you'll feel as if you were right smack dab in the middle of everything. Overall this is a great track, and there's really not much more to say other than you should warn your neighbors ahead of time.
Extras
Though I've come to terms with the fact that, yet again, there's no sign of what would presumably be an engaging commentary track from Christopher Nolan included in the extras here, what is included on the second Blu-ray disc of the set is fairly entertaining and informational high definition stuff. First up though is a feature not included on either disc, Warner's The Dark Knight Rises FX HD App, which can be downloaded from iTunes or Google Play and will act as a sort of second screen option for more extras and behind-the-scenes material synced with viewing the film. As of this writing the feature is not yet active, but if it works like similar features--such as the app paired with Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows--it should be a worthwhile extra to download and try out, given that you have a compatible device of course.
The major production featurette, "Ending The Knight", clocks in at right around 70-minutes, and while not as extensive as the recent "Furious Gods" documentary that accompanied Prometheus on that film's 3D Blu-ray presentation, the multi-part feature is pretty great in its own right. Along with pieces focusing on the production (The Prologue: High Altitude Hijacking, Beneath Gotham, Return to the Batcave, Batman vs Bane, The Bat, Armory Accepted, Gameday Destruction, Demolishing a City Street, The Pit, The Chant, The War on Wall Street and Race to the Reactor), you also get profiles on the characters of Bruce Wayne/Batman, Bane and Selina Kyle/Catwoman. Rounding out these are features based on filming in the IMAX format (Shadows & Light in Large Format) and "The End of A Legend", which focuses on the trilogy as a whole and gives many involved with the production of the trilogy a chance to reflect on the experience.
As good the production featurette is though, I really enjoyed "The Batmobile" even more. True, it really isn't an extra that focuses exclusively on The Dark Knight Rises, but it's great trip down memory lane looking back at the various incarnations of Batman's most iconic ride. Featuring the participation of Christopher Nolan, Tim Burton, Joel Shumacher and a host of artists and writers it's an unexpectedly fun hour of Batman nostalgia. The rest of the features are rounded out with theatrical trailers for The Dark Knight Rises, an art gallery (both also on the second disc), and UltraViolet and standard definition copies of the film available through a download code and on the third disc of the set respectively.
Overall
The Dark Knight Rises is a very good capper to Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, and while my preference towards the more comic book oriented aspects of the character and the world in which he inhabits don't exactly jive with Nolan and company's vision, I've enjoyed these films nonetheless. If ranking the trilogy, I'd have to order them best to least (none of these films could be described as worst) in the order in which they were released. Warner Home Video's Blu-ray presentation features an excellent video track coupled with one of the best audio tracks you're likely to find on the format, along with a couple of hours worth of quality extras that leave you wanting a bit more. Overall, this is a definite purchase and should be near the top of your Xmas list.
Review by Matt Joseph
Advertisements
I found it very entertaining and love Hardy's Bane, but I have massive issues with the real-world politics I'm reading below the surface and think the nonsense plot points really do start to hurt it by the third act. I shouldn't exactly complain, since I enjoyed Prometheus beyond it's dumb narrative, but for whatever reason I can't accept the lapses here. The Batman fan in me also doesn't like a Batman that quits twice in the same movie, but that's really not fair of me considering that this is merely a version of an eclectic character. I'm hoping the next iteration learns from both the good and bad parts of Nolan's movies.
I just wish there weren't so many new characters in the movie. I didn't particularly care for Blake, and Mathew Modine's character was such a waste of screen time. I would have done away with both of them if it meant having more screen time with Catwoman or Gordon.
I also disapproved of the portrayal of Alfred from going to a 110% committed to Bruce's goal to a "I want you to have a normal life so badly that I'm just going to abandon you for my own selfish reasons". For god's sakes Alfred, Bruce is an adult. He's doing what he thinks is right, and as a result has saved the lives of countless innocents by doing so. This is so out of character and totally not what Alfred is about.
I also disapproved of the portrayal of Alfred from going to a 110% committed to Bruce's goal to a "I want you to have a normal life so badly that I'm just going to abandon you for my own selfish reasons". For god's sakes Alfred, Bruce is an adult. He's doing what he thinks is right, and as a result has saved the lives of countless innocents by doing so. This is so out of character and totally not what Alfred is about.
After seeing the film on Imax first then a traditional framed digital presentation. I'm a bit disappointed with the overall sharpness of the film on Blu ray, especially the 35MM footage VS the Imax footage. Many shots filmed in 35mm are out of focus constantly. It's like they used the up-converted files that were made for IMAX then downgraded them for Blu ray. I'm not sure what they did, but when compared to the sharpness on a film like The Avengers, I'm a bit letdown.
Also, way way way to dark on Blu ray. I never noticed it this dark in the theater. I finally tweaked my TV (after watching for about a half hour, it was driving me nuts) which I haven't touch the color, etc since I got it this spring.
The special features are great, I would have loves some more about how they did the makeup on Bane to cover Tom's tattoos.
I'm still love the film, just a bit disappointed in the image being a bit dark and the 35MM footage being a bit soft.
Also, way way way to dark on Blu ray. I never noticed it this dark in the theater. I finally tweaked my TV (after watching for about a half hour, it was driving me nuts) which I haven't touch the color, etc since I got it this spring.
The special features are great, I would have loves some more about how they did the makeup on Bane to cover Tom's tattoos.
I'm still love the film, just a bit disappointed in the image being a bit dark and the 35MM footage being a bit soft.
Wow, Matt. I wish I could buy you a drink and discuss this more. You're spot-on with everything I've been telling people about this franchise. Mask of the Phantasm is still my favorite Batman flick, and the animated series from the early 90s as a whole is my all-time favorite Batman entity.
And all of my friends disagree, but I agree that Batman Begins is the king of this trilogy.
Excellent review. Cheers!
And all of my friends disagree, but I agree that Batman Begins is the king of this trilogy.
Excellent review. Cheers!
I LOVED this movie. I agree with some issues but the film is just so good I can forgive them. I also love that we finally get a physically imposing villain. One of the 2 twists at the end doesn't really sit well with me but I'll say no more. I liked this better than TDK. I just think the story feels more epic and got me more involved. Ledger was a more memorable villain but this film is more involving IMO. Honestly there were times in TDK i had no clue what was going on. Also that film kept throwing too much at us too late in the game.
These are my thoughts exactly for the whole trilogy, great review Matt!
While I might not necessarily agree with you on all points, I think this is a tremendously well written review that argues persuasively and reasonably a well considered opinion. This is an extremely high standard of reviewing on display here.
Pretty damned spot-on review there, Matt.
Watched it last night with the Missus. The movie really left me cold when I saw it at the cinema, a c**p, distorting audio system really not helping matters - virtually none of bane's dialogue could be picked out. I have real problems with Alfred merely walking out on Bruce Wayne, as it takes a p*ss on the entire legacy of Batman to have him do so. The fact that Bats just quit because of the death of Ms Dawes is another huge bone of contention - it took the death of two people close to Wayne to turn him into Gotham's protector, but just a single one to make him hang up the cowel?
Watching it again, I really enjoyed it, probably because the annoying turns in the plot have had time to grow a scab over them. It's a shame that they went down the ol' "expensive sh*t that doesn't exist" route with The Bat, but it was the only way they could have tied up the ending, short of using Spider-Man 2's device of "Drown it!" when a reactor is going critical. Bane is terrific, Catwoman is underused, Blake is likeable and nice to see that a certain cast member of Shirley Valentine makes a better fist of an accent here. With the spotlight thrown on Gordon and his family (particularly Barbara) which has made many speculate that Nolan might have had The Killing Joke in the back of his mind for the 3rd movie. This was obviously torpedoed with Heath Ledger entering a state of permanent death, and a real shame for a number of reasons.
The image suffers from the dreaded "black crush" where detail in the shadows is wiped out through darkness being a little too deep - not as originally intended. Apart from that, the image really is damned nice, especially when it switches to IMAX. I will admit that the changeover is more noticable here than it was before, and not just because a greater percentage of it is shot that way. A perfect example comes near the end, when one of the three trucks comes to an abrupt halt after an excellent IMAX chase and the drivers get out. Cutting to a reverse on them, it switches back to 35mm, and it kicks you right out of the flow, and this is a far cry from cutting between exteriors and interiors with the system.
The audio was pretty damned good, with the music pounding away with an alarming ferocity. There were a few instances of a certain thing which p*sses me off on audio mixes, that being where a gunshot is put really loud into one of the rear speakers, at a volume which could well do damage to those listening at high enough volumes - these ususally come as the capper to a quiet moment of tension, and is a bit of a cheap trick. If you are going to enter the realms of "unreality" then the audio on The Bat is just amazing. On its inital fly-past, it travels from front to back via a seamless transition, with some of the heaviest bass I have ever encountered - and I have the Japanese LaserDisc of Star Wars: Episode 1. The floorboards literally shook, and even the Missus was impressed, noting how over-cranked the audio was when we saw it at the cinema - a genuinely painful experience, I have to say. BTW, all of Bane's dialogue was perfectly audiable on Blu, and deeply cool to have it spread across the front three speakers, as well as the subwoofer.
Well, I liked The Dark Knight Rises much more this time, in spite of a few major elements which rubbed me up the wrong way. I suspect a number of hostile opinions will change when others left cold by their initial viewing revisit it.
WILSON BRO (N)
Watched it last night with the Missus. The movie really left me cold when I saw it at the cinema, a c**p, distorting audio system really not helping matters - virtually none of bane's dialogue could be picked out. I have real problems with Alfred merely walking out on Bruce Wayne, as it takes a p*ss on the entire legacy of Batman to have him do so. The fact that Bats just quit because of the death of Ms Dawes is another huge bone of contention - it took the death of two people close to Wayne to turn him into Gotham's protector, but just a single one to make him hang up the cowel?
Watching it again, I really enjoyed it, probably because the annoying turns in the plot have had time to grow a scab over them. It's a shame that they went down the ol' "expensive sh*t that doesn't exist" route with The Bat, but it was the only way they could have tied up the ending, short of using Spider-Man 2's device of "Drown it!" when a reactor is going critical. Bane is terrific, Catwoman is underused, Blake is likeable and nice to see that a certain cast member of Shirley Valentine makes a better fist of an accent here. With the spotlight thrown on Gordon and his family (particularly Barbara) which has made many speculate that Nolan might have had The Killing Joke in the back of his mind for the 3rd movie. This was obviously torpedoed with Heath Ledger entering a state of permanent death, and a real shame for a number of reasons.
The image suffers from the dreaded "black crush" where detail in the shadows is wiped out through darkness being a little too deep - not as originally intended. Apart from that, the image really is damned nice, especially when it switches to IMAX. I will admit that the changeover is more noticable here than it was before, and not just because a greater percentage of it is shot that way. A perfect example comes near the end, when one of the three trucks comes to an abrupt halt after an excellent IMAX chase and the drivers get out. Cutting to a reverse on them, it switches back to 35mm, and it kicks you right out of the flow, and this is a far cry from cutting between exteriors and interiors with the system.
The audio was pretty damned good, with the music pounding away with an alarming ferocity. There were a few instances of a certain thing which p*sses me off on audio mixes, that being where a gunshot is put really loud into one of the rear speakers, at a volume which could well do damage to those listening at high enough volumes - these ususally come as the capper to a quiet moment of tension, and is a bit of a cheap trick. If you are going to enter the realms of "unreality" then the audio on The Bat is just amazing. On its inital fly-past, it travels from front to back via a seamless transition, with some of the heaviest bass I have ever encountered - and I have the Japanese LaserDisc of Star Wars: Episode 1. The floorboards literally shook, and even the Missus was impressed, noting how over-cranked the audio was when we saw it at the cinema - a genuinely painful experience, I have to say. BTW, all of Bane's dialogue was perfectly audiable on Blu, and deeply cool to have it spread across the front three speakers, as well as the subwoofer.
Well, I liked The Dark Knight Rises much more this time, in spite of a few major elements which rubbed me up the wrong way. I suspect a number of hostile opinions will change when others left cold by their initial viewing revisit it.
WILSON BRO (N)
I am annoyed with the Batman giving up and Alfred quitting parts too. I enjoyed the movie, but it isn't as good as the other two
Well, for better or worse, this was the ending to the trilogy, and I came away very satisfied with it. That is all...
Some material may be inappropriate for children under 13
Disc Details
Release Date:
4th December 2012
Discs:
3
Disc Type:
Blu-ray Disc
RCE:
No
Video:
1080p
Aspect:
1.78:1
Anamorphic:
Yes
Colour:
Yes
Audio:
DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 English, Dolby Digital 5.1 French, Spanish & Portuguese, Dolby Digital 2.0 English
Subtitles:
English, French, Spanish
Extras:
Featurettes, The Dark Knight Rises FX HD App (iOS Devices), Trailers, Ultraviolet Digial Copy
Easter Egg:
No
Feature Details
Director:
Christopher Nolan
Cast:
Christian Bale, Anne Hathaway, Tom Hardy
Genre:
Action, Adventure and Fantasy
Length:
165 minutes
Ratings
Awards
Amazon.com
FOLLOW DVDACTIVE
Follow our updates
OTHER INTERESTING STUFF
Reviewer Agony
Shark Attack 3: Megalodon
UK - DVD R2
Space Buddies
US - BD RA
Dead and Deader
US - DVD R1
Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed
UK - DVD R2
Darkest Hour, The
UK - DVD R2
New Editorials
SXSW Film 2013 - Part 1
US - DVD | HD | BD
Will streaming kill physical media?
DVD | HD | BD
Gabe's 2012 Wrap-Up
DVD | BD
Netflix Reviewed
UK - DVD | HD | BD
Guest Column: Dark Shadows on DVD
US - DVD R1
New Easter Eggs
Star Wars: The Clone Wars - The Complete Season Two
UK - BD
Memento
UK - BD RB
Battlestar Galactica: The Plan
UK - BD
Moon
UK - BD
Star Wars: The Clone Wars - The Complete Season One
UK - BD
Most Talked About
Oldboy (2013)
US - BD RA
Alexander: The Ultimate Cut
US - BD RA
The Wolf of Wall Street
US - DVD R1 | BD RA
Shadow: Collector's Edition, The
US - BD RA
Grandmaster, The
US - BD RA
As much as I love TDK and Ledger, I think it's the one I'd gravitate to last. It's great, it's realistic, but I think the 2nd half just gets bogged down. RISES has it's issues, I'm not blind to it, but man, it is a ton of fun.
I personally love that you don't see Batman until 40mins in, makes the anticipation for when he does show up and Zimmer's score kicks in amazing! I love that Rises (and this trilogy as a whole) gave time to focus on Bruce Wayne as a character and not just Batman - it was great and I was totally wrapped up in it. At the end of the day, when s**t is hitting the fan, as an audience you care about the guy under the mask, and Nolan nailed that.